Panel minutes for 4 December 2025
Minutes of the Digital Advisory Panel (DAP) Meeting
4 December 2025, 13:30 to 15:00 Virtual meeting via Microsoft Teams
Panel Members:
- Christian McMahon (Chair)
- Francine Bennett
- Paul Smith
- Darren Williams.
In attendance: REDACTED.
Apologies: None.
1. Welcome, apologies and declarations of interest
Attendees were welcomed to the meeting and apologies noted.
There were no new declarations of interest.
2. Minutes of previous meetings
The minutes of the last meeting held on 16 October 2025 were approved as a true record of the meeting.
REDACTED
Review of actions
Not applicable
3. Illegal gambling: update
DAP members received an update on data recently published on illegal gambling, the focus being on online illegal gambling.
The Gambling Commission has published 4 chapters of data so far on illegal gambling.
The first chapter was on consumer motivations. Headline findings were:
- engagement with illegal gambling websites is typically supplementary rather than exclusive
- respondents most commonly reported using illegal gambling websites to engage in online betting on football, online bingo, online fruit or slot games and virtual gaming
- as with legal gambling websites, reported engagement with illegal gambling websites also tends to be highest among:
- men
- younger individuals (18 to 24 years)
- those who gamble more frequently
- those who score 8 or more on the Problem Gambling Survey Index (PGSI).
The second chapter of published data covered engagement data and trends. Regarding indicators of prevalence of motivations, the Data Team used Similarweb to explore estimates of search term volumes in relation to motivations of consumers looking for illegal gambling websites. They used this information to develop a data collection methodology. This work supports the Enforcement Team in their work to close down these sites.
One DAP member asked if this work covers other areas of online gambling, for example, in-app. The Commission considers this work to be one piece of the puzzle and is not seeing any increase in the estimated engagement of traffic. This does not however account for other areas and the Commission is looking at how to develop this.
The third chapter was on the mechanisms used to tackle the market from an enforcement perspective. The data helps the enforcement team to allocate their resources, for example, targeting domain names being used and the suspension of websites being searched for.
DAP members were given an overview of some of the challenges of estimating the size of the illegal online market for example, additional websites can be created after a website has been closed down. The websites replicate licensed websites very closely, which is why some consumers do not realise they are on an illegal site. The Commission works with other financial agencies to help with closing down these sites and with other related problems such as credit card purchases.
A DAP member noted that the major app stores make it difficult to use illegal gambling apps, and then questioned how consumers are then finding and accessing them. This is an area that the Commission will be looking at. There are additional issues to this point, for example, gambling can take place in messenger apps, such as Telegram. The Data Team would be open to advice on in-app activities.
The fourth chapter of published data focused on the challenges of estimating the size of the illegal online market. At this stage, the Commission will not be providing an official number on the size of the illegal gambling market, it will only do so when it can be confident in the numbers and with substantive evidence to support those numbers. Instead, the Commission has published its methodologies in order to be transparent about where the Commission is currently at in the process.
The Commission has liaised with other European regulators to discuss some of the challenges and methods. The UK has a high channelisation rate, and in proportion to other countries it seems its market is smaller however, the Commission’s enforcement team continue to collaborate with other jurisdictions to move this work forward.
REDACTED
REDACTED
REDACTED
REDACTED
In addition, how Virtual Private Network (VPN) traffic can be accounted for is lacking. Currently the Data Team are carrying out survey data research, and one of the questions asked in the consumer research survey was how consumers use a VPN and using that figure as an estimation of VPN usage. The Data Team would welcome thoughts from DAP members on how VPN traffic can be tracked.
DAP members had views on how VPN data can be tracked and the challenges around such tracking.
One DAP member commented that there is currently a lot of scrutiny on age verification – nobody can tell if any laws are being broken and it is an even more difficult time to be getting those numbers.
Another DAP member remarked that there have been ways in the past to access VPN data, by age restrictions for example, but a lot of AI companies are spending hundreds of billions of dollars scraping the web and trying to keep that under the radar. It is cheap and easy to connect to a VPN from anywhere around the world. At this stage it would be very difficult to get a metric on this.
Another DAP member said there have been quite a few articles recently about Ofcom trying to monitor VPN usage and it might be useful for the Data Team to contact Ofcom to explore this further.
The Commission has not carried out a lot of work yet on crypto gambling, but it is an area that it wants to look into further and would welcome some generic advice from DAP members.
DAP members responded:
- crypto is available and it is the value of the currency and its validity which are large areas to look at: eventually, it is likely that there will be a legal tender for crypto, in line with the pound, but in digital form
- one DAP member commented that his organisation requires a lot of anti-money laundring (AML) requirements on crypto and only regulated industries will care about those; if the websites are illegal then they can use anonymous pay wallets to deposit into illegal gambling websites
- the GC have not yet looked at the ‘dark web’ as an area of priority, but will most likely do so at a later stage.
REDACTED
REDACTED
REDACTED
4. Intelligence Team update
Intelligence Commission officials introduced themselves to the DAP members.
DAP members received an overview of the Intelligence Team and the work they do. Key highlights include:
- REDACTED
- REDACTED
- REDACTED
- outcomes of the Commission’s Intelligence work include:
- sharing information with the Commission’s Compliance Team REDACTED
- escalating any issue of concern, novel or contentious, through to the Commission’s Enforcement Team
- dissemination of information to relevant stakeholders REDACTED
- information held by the Intelligence Team REDACTED.
DAP members also received an overview of annual reporting of intelligence and internal and external disseminations of intelligence for 2025.
The DAP Chair thanked Commission Intelligence officials for a fascinating presentation and went on to ask what is the average turnaround of cases? A Commission official responded that it varies for example, cases on unlicensed websites require a fast turnaround, whilst other cases might take months to develop if other agencies are involved, such as the police, HMRC and so on.
REDACTED
5. Any other business
DAP members noted that the session on Intelligence had been very useful and informative and that it will be good to receive a presentation from a different business area every 1 in 4 meetings, as discussed previously.
(Meeting closed at 14:30)
REDACTED